Research and Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment Act 8 J
「Research and Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment Act 8 J」於資料集「EPQSummary_EnvironmentalImpactAssessment」由單位「行政院環境保護署」的陳先生所提供，聯繫電話是02-2311-7722#2386，最近更新時間為：2023-07-30 01:01:43。 欄位Project Title的內容是Research and Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment Act 8 Judgement Guideline Project Work Plan ， 欄位Project Subject的內容是This project aims at exploring how to apply Environmental Impact Assessment Act Article 8, especially the requirement provides that “the likelihood of significant impact on the environment”. Although Article 19 of the Administrative Regulation Related to the Application of Environmental Impact Assessment Act provides 8 specific situations, the courts take hard look doctrine to review those judgements made by expert committee in the EIA process. The courts often argue that the EIA resolutions are illegal because they contain judgement flaws or abuse of judgement. The concepts of “the likelihood of significant impact on the environment” are so vague that the administrative courts suggest the Environmental Protection Agency should propose or establish a clear identification method to make those requirements more concrete than before. Therefore, this project made a comprehensive survey, including the legislation history of EIA Act, similar Acts of foreign countries, EIA reports done by developers, EIA resolutions, and judicial judgements.
This project analyzed 158 cases relating to whether the second phase of EIA is necessary to be done. It was found that most of their considerations included significantly adverse influences on environmental resources or environmental characteristics, obviously exceeded the environmental quality standards and exceeded tolerant capacity of local environment. However, it is difficult to generalize a conclusion from a quantitative perspective. On the other hand, this project also reviewed over 44 judgements done by administrative courts. It was found that many judges emphasized the due process of law, well-reasoned, the procedural rights of local citizens to participate the EIA, the complicated relations between EIA resolutions and section 1 article 93 of the Administrative Procedural Act, and whether the resolutions of EIA were based on the record of the meeting. After summarizing all the analysis coming from reviewing EIA resolutions and judgements done by administrative courts, this project established common and specific criteria for general application of the EIA cases. Because quantitative factors are difficult to comply with all scientific verification requirements, this project suggested that it may be proper to adopt the bases set by the amendment of Administrative Regulation of EIA firstly and refer to the criteria secondly.
Based on pragmatic research methods, many dialogues between legal professors and scientific scholars and opinions collected from the public, this project establish “CRITERIA Related to the Likelihood of Significant Impact on the Environment for Judgement of EIA Committee. The outcome of this project may become an effective guideline for the EPA, and experts of EIA Committee. The response of the administrative courts is noteworthy. ， 欄位Project Year的內容是2014 ， 欄位Organizer的內容是Department of Comprehensive Planning ， 欄位Executive Unit的內容是國立臺北科技大學 ， 欄位Reporting download URL的內容是https://epq.epa.gov.tw/ProjectDoc/FileDownload?fid=98044&proj_id=1039239422&doc_kind=1 ， 欄位Publish Date的內容是20151001 。
Project Title
Research and Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment Act 8 Judgement Guideline Project Work Plan
Project Subject
This project aims at exploring how to apply Environmental Impact Assessment Act Article 8, especially the requirement provides that “the likelihood of significant impact on the environment”. Although Article 19 of the Administrative Regulation Related to the Application of Environmental Impact Assessment Act provides 8 specific situations, the courts take hard look doctrine to review those judgements made by expert committee in the EIA process. The courts often argue that the EIA resolutions are illegal because they contain judgement flaws or abuse of judgement. The concepts of “the likelihood of significant impact on the environment” are so vague that the administrative courts suggest the Environmental Protection Agency should propose or establish a clear identification method to make those requirements more concrete than before. Therefore, this project made a comprehensive survey, including the legislation history of EIA Act, similar Acts of foreign countries, EIA reports done by developers, EIA resolutions, and judicial judgements. This project analyzed 158 cases relating to whether the second phase of EIA is necessary to be done. It was found that most of their considerations included significantly adverse influences on environmental resources or environmental characteristics, obviously exceeded the environmental quality standards and exceeded tolerant capacity of local environment. However, it is difficult to generalize a conclusion from a quantitative perspective. On the other hand, this project also reviewed over 44 judgements done by administrative courts. It was found that many judges emphasized the due process of law, well-reasoned, the procedural rights of local citizens to participate the EIA, the complicated relations between EIA resolutions and section 1 article 93 of the Administrative Procedural Act, and whether the resolutions of EIA were based on the record of the meeting. After summarizing all the analysis coming from reviewing EIA resolutions and judgements done by administrative courts, this project established common and specific criteria for general application of the EIA cases. Because quantitative factors are difficult to comply with all scientific verification requirements, this project suggested that it may be proper to adopt the bases set by the amendment of Administrative Regulation of EIA firstly and refer to the criteria secondly. Based on pragmatic research methods, many dialogues between legal professors and scientific scholars and opinions collected from the public, this project establish “CRITERIA Related to the Likelihood of Significant Impact on the Environment for Judgement of EIA Committee. The outcome of this project may become an effective guideline for the EPA, and experts of EIA Committee. The response of the administrative courts is noteworthy.
Project Year
2014
Organizer
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Executive Unit
國立臺北科技大學
Reporting download URL
https://epq.epa.gov.tw/ProjectDoc/FileDownload?fid=98044&proj_id=1039239422&doc_kind=1
Publish Date
20151001
「Research and Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment Act 8 J」所屬的資料集：「EPQSummary_EnvironmentalImpactAssessment」的其他資料
-2019-
Project Title：
-
Project Subject：
-
Project Year：
2019
Organizer：
Environmental Protection Bureau, Taichung City
Project Title：
Environmental resource management and decision-making supporting project in 2013
Project Subject：
The aim of this project is to assist the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Committee in reviewin
Project Year：
2012
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Environmental Impact Assessment Inquiry Application System Management and Maintenance Project
Project Subject：
This project had developed many results this year in the Environmental Impact Assessment inquiry app
Project Year：
2021
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
The Study on Experts Mechanism in the Process of Environment Impact Assessments
Project Subject：
This study conducts two approaches in evaluating and exploring expert mechanism within Environment I
Project Year：
2011
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
The Analysis of Greenhouse Gas Periodic Regulatory Goal Construction and Administrative Support
Project Subject：
This project aims to conven and orgnize the administrative processes of Greenhouse Gas periodic regu
Project Year：
2016
Organizer：
Office of Greenhouse Gases Reduction Management
Project Title：
"The Supervision Project for Environmental Impact Assessment"
Project Subject：
"The scope of the project was the review and supervision the approved environmental impact assessmen
Project Year：
2018
Organizer：
"Bureau of Environmental Inspection"
Project Title：
Strategic Environmental Assessment on Changes in Scope of the Drinking Water Source
Project Subject：
It had been delineated and issued eighty-six of the drinking water source quality protection area an
Project Year：
2012
Organizer：
Department of Environmental Sanitation ＆amp; Toxic Substance Management
Project Title：
""
Project Subject：
"The purposes of this project are to investigate the conditions of dam in Taiwan, to list the priori
Project Year：
2015
Organizer：
"Solution integration office"
"-"2019"-"
Project Title：
"-"
Project Subject：
"-"
Project Year：
2019
Organizer：
"Environmental Protection Bureau, Taichung City"
Project Title：
Total Load Control Plan for Environmental Impact Assessment in Slope-Land Areas—Case Study of Chia-Y
Project Subject：
According to the environmental carrying capacity, total load control aimed to develop and use enviro
Project Year：
2003
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Study on Revising Regulations for Reviewing of Environmental Impact Assessment and Directions
Project Subject：
Environmental Impact Assessment （EIA） Act has been enforced since 1994. The purpose of the EIA syste
Project Year：
2014
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Project for Assistance on Holding Environmental Impact Assessment Review Meetings
Project Subject：
To improve the efficiency and quality of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) review, document
Project Year：
2014
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Reorganize and buildup background information of Environmental Impact assessment
Project Subject：
In the end of 1994, The Environmental impact assessment Law lawmaking and passes, however, whether r
Project Year：
2003
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Evaluation of Technical Consulting Firms on Environmental Impact Assessment in Fiscal Year 91
Project Subject：
The Environmental Protection Administration (EPA) has started the work of “Technical Consulting Firm
Project Year：
2002
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
A Study of State Compensation for EIA
Project Subject：
The purpose of this study is to examine the environmental impact assessment (EIA) reports invalidate
Project Year：
2014
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
"Environmental impact assessment review operations Project after the Implementation of the Geology A
Project Subject：
"Geology Act. is promulgated by the Ministry of Economic Affairs on December 1st 2011. “Geologically
Project Year：
2019
Organizer：
"Department of Comprehensive Planning"
Project Title：
"Project for Assistance on Holding EIA Review Meetings in 2020, Evaluation of EIA Technical Consulti
Project Subject：
"The main objective of this project is to improve the efficiency and quality of the Environmental Im
Project Year：
2020
Organizer：
"Department of Comprehensive Planning"
Project Title：
The Supervision Project for Environmental Impact Assessment
Project Subject：
This annual project reviewed and supervised the approved environmental impact assessment (EIA) repor
Project Year：
2012
Organizer：
Bureau of Environmental Inspection
Project Title：
Study on Cumulative Environmental Impacts Assessment Standard and Integrate to Geographic Informatio
Project Subject：
This study continues the project of ”Study on Cumulative Environmental Impacts Assessment Standard a
Project Year：
2003
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
A study of voluntary carbon reduction mechanism design and cost-benefit analysis on GHGs management
Project Subject：
There are three main work items in this project; the implementation results achieved for each work i
Project Year：
2020
Organizer：
Department of Environmental Sanitation ＆amp; Toxic Substance Management
Project Title：
"A Study of the Application of Technical Guidelines for Social Impact Assessment in Environmental Im
Project Subject：
"The aim of environmental impact assessment (EIA) is to make the potential impacts of development pr
Project Year：
2016
Organizer：
"Department of Comprehensive Planning"
Project Title：
The Assessment of Toxic and Chemical Substance Management Fund and the Academia-Industry Collaborati
Project Subject：
The project aims to assess the impact of the income and expenditure of chemical fund tuition fees. A
Project Year：
2022
Organizer：
Toxic and Chemical Substances Bureau
Project Title：
The Standard Operating Procedure and the model establishment of the Environmental Impact Assessment
Project Subject：
The main content of the project is coordinating ways to the public opinion investigation of all sort
Project Year：
2005
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
-2018-
Project Title：
-
Project Subject：
-
Project Year：
2018
Organizer：
Environmental Protection Bureau, Taichung City
Project Title：
"Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment and decision-making supporting project in 2019"
Project Subject：
"The 2019 Analysis of Environmental Impact Assessment and decision-making supporting project was con
Project Year：
2019
Organizer：
"Department of Comprehensive Planning"
Project Title：
A Study of the Application of Technical Guidelines for Social Impact Assessment in Environmental Imp
Project Subject：
The aim of environmental impact assessment (EIA) is to make the potential impacts of development pro
Project Year：
2016
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
The EIA Management Strategies of the Development Activity in Reservoir Watersheds
Project Subject：
This project’s aim is to collect, research and analyze the background information of the 96 reservoi
Project Year：
2012
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
Enhanced Environmental Impact Assessment Supervisory and law Enforcement Project 2022
Project Subject：
This plan is intended to assist Environmental Protection Administration with the following: (1) Assi
Project Year：
2022
Organizer：
Bureau of Environmental Inspection
Project Title：
Environmental resource management and decision-making supporting project in 2015
Project Subject：
The 2015 environmental resource management and decision support project was contracted to assist the
Project Year：
2015
Organizer：
Department of Comprehensive Planning
Project Title：
"The Supervision Project for Environmental Impact Assessment"
Project Subject：
"This annual project reviewed and supervised the approved environmental impact assessment (EIA) repo
Project Year：
2013
Organizer：
"Bureau of Environmental Inspection"
行政院環境保護署 的其他資料集
公告飲用水水質處理藥劑
不定期更新更新,40黃先生 | 02-23117722-2881 | 2023-08-09 01:05:33
行政院環境保護署環保專案摘要資料_環境教育
不定期更新更新,230陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2023-07-30 01:01:58
行政院環境保護署毒性化學物質許可及申報資料
每3月更新,265許先生 | 02-23117722#2865 | 2023-07-30 01:03:49
行政院環境保護署旅館或觀光旅館之興建或擴建類別環境影響說明書
每2月更新,55黃先生 | 02-23117722#2748 | 2023-08-05 01:01:08
行政院環境保護署光化測站(忠明)小時值資料
不定期更新更新,110陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2023-08-07 01:03:29
行政院環境保護署
台灣地區垃圾處理場（廠）互惠緊急支援要點
不定期更新,32蔡先生 | 04-2252-1718#53508 | 2022-01-15 01:13:13
行政院環境保護署環評主管機關受理審查之環境影響調查報告
每2月更新,82黃先生 | 02-23117722#2748 | 2023-08-05 01:01:16
行政院環境保護署彰濱工業區環境監測資料
每3月更新,47陳先生 | 04-22521718#51207 | 2023-08-09 01:05:05
行政院環境保護署不法利得宣導資料
不定期更新更新,63全先生 | (04)2252-1718#337 | 2023-08-09 01:04:30
行政院環境保護署環保署職員官等年齡統計資料
不定期更新更新,39黃小姐 | 02-23117722分機2132 | 2022-01-15 01:12:56
行政院環境保護署
持久性有機污染物斯德哥爾摩公約國家實施計畫成果報告
每年更新更新,36劉小姐 | 23257399#55531 | 2022-01-15 01:10:06
行政院環境保護署室內空氣品質公告場所定期檢測結果
不定期更新更新,115蔣小姐 | 02-23117722#6406 | 2023-07-30 01:04:48
行政院環境保護署環境用藥販賣業許可執照資料
每3月更新,122薛先生 | 02-2325-7399#55413 | 2023-07-27 01:02:58
行政院環境保護署土壤污染物監測及管制標準
不定期更新更新,60王先生 | 02-23832389#8307 | 2022-01-14 01:20:21
行政院環境保護署補助地方設置巨大廢棄物回收再利用廠一覽
不定期更新更新,40林小姐 | 04-22521718#53511 | 2023-08-07 00:59:54
行政院環境保護署
臺東縣水量水質自動監測連線傳輸監測紀錄值即時資料集
不定期更新更新,41程先生 | 02-2311-7722#2833 | 2023-08-09 01:04:06
行政院環境保護署核能四廠環境監測資料
不定期更新更新,34陳先生 | 04-22521718#51207 | 2022-01-14 01:22:00
行政院環境保護署重點事業廢棄物-生物醫療廢棄物之處理方式
每月更新更新,136陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2682 | 2022-01-14 01:24:07
行政院環境保護署日累積雨量(每月更新)
每1月更新,121陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2023-08-03 01:05:26
行政院環境保護署機車排氣定期檢驗資料
不定期更新更新,118謝小姐 | 02-2371-2121#6310 | 2022-01-14 01:18:28
行政院環境保護署
重點事業廢棄物-一般污泥之產出及清理流向
每月更新更新,124陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2682 | 2022-01-14 01:24:16
行政院環境保護署車機型號妥善率報表
每月更新更新,102林先生 | 02-2325-7399#55232 | 2022-01-14 01:18:34
行政院環境保護署列管公廁個數
每年更新更新,112謝小姐 | 02-23117722#2103 | 2022-01-14 01:22:36
行政院環境保護署空氣污染排放量推估結果
每2年更新,93劉小姐 | 02-23117722#6111 | 2023-07-30 01:04:49
行政院環境保護署空氣品質小時值_臺中市_沙鹿站
每小時更新更新,130謝小姐 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2022-01-14 01:04:01
行政院環境保護署
空氣品質預報資料
30分鐘更新,94謝小姐 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2022-01-15 01:00:10
行政院環境保護署環境教育人員認證展延研習30小時課程認可審查作業說明
不定期更新更新,51盧小姐 | (03)4020789分機606 | 2023-08-09 01:05:19
行政院環境保護署縣市(臺北市)小時值-每小時
每1時更新,133陳先生 | 02-2311-7722#2386 | 2023-08-02 00:58:56
行政院環境保護署環保署毒物及化學物質局補、捐(獎)助團體及個人情形表
每季更新更新,41陳小姐 | 02-23257399#55434,02-23257399#55432 | 2022-01-15 01:09:58
行政院環境保護署各級環保單位歲出決算
每月更新更新,75謝小姐 | 02-23117722#2103 | 2022-01-14 01:21:35
行政院環境保護署